Athol Books Magazine Articles

Articles

All Articles
Articles By Author
Articles By Magazine
Articles By Subject
Full Text Search

Athol Books

Aubane Historical Society
The Heresiarch Website
Athol Books Online Sales
Athol Books Home Page
Archive Of Articles From Church & State
Archive Of Editorials From Church & State
Archive Of Articles From Irish Political Review
Archive Of Editorials From Irish Political Review
Belfast Historical & Educational Society
Athol Books Secure Online Sales

Other Sites

Irish Writer Desmond Fennell
The Bevin Society
David Morrison's Website

Subscribe Securely To
Athol Books Magazines

Church & State (Print) Church & State (Digital)
Irish Foreign Affairs (Print) Irish Foreign Affairs (Digital)
Irish Political Review (Print) Irish Political Review (Digital)
Problems Problems
From: Irish Political Review: Editorials
Date: November, 2016
By: Editorial

Constitutional Nationalism!

Constitutional Nationalism!
The futility of Irish Constitutional Nationalism at Westminster was demonstrated yet again at the Commons debate on Syria, but essentially on Russia, on October 11th, when Mark Durkan intervened in an effort to broaden the moral concern, on the basis of the principles that were being invoked, to include atrocities which it would be of no benefit to Britain to condemn. He asked:

"Does the Foreign Secretary not think that more weight would be attached to the strength of his words about the International Criminal Court if the regime of President al-Bashir of Sudan—who has also been bombing his people from the air, who has recently been seen to be using chemical weapons against them, and who has been indicted by the International Criminal Court for genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity—was not now being embraced by the UK Government through the UK-Sudan strategic dialogue as a partner in countering terrorism and managing migration?_"___

The Foreign Secretary responded:

"I take that point very sincerely, but it is vital that we concentrate our efforts and our censure on the Russians and on the Assad regime, who are primarily responsible for what is going on in Syria now. We can get lost endlessly in all sorts of moral equivalences…"

Political morality is interest-oriented. It always has been everywhere, and nowhere as much as in Britain.

The mathematical axiom, that two things which are equal to the same thing are equal to each other, does not hold good in political and social affairs. Such "moral equivalences" are empty debating points. Political morality is national. England has had its singularly national morality for about half a millennium and, at the moment when it is striking out on its own again, it has no intention of dissolving itself into moral equivalences.

It has its own absolute morality determined by its interest, and there is an effective consensus about this within Constitutional politics. Durkan just struck a jarringly irrelevant note. He did so because the Constitutionalism of the SDLP is merely imitative. It has never been a participant in the Constitutional system by which Britain is governed, and it has developed no insider sense of what is appropriate.
The founder-leader of the SDLP—Gerry Fitt, who tried hard to be a Brit—used to deplore the "tribalism" of the people he had to deal with in the Six Counties, but it is in Westminster that something like a real tribal spirit operates. It functions as a sort of Council of Elders which irresistibly generates substantial consensus, subverts the expression of earnest antagonism, and marginalises those who do not succumb to the influence of the obligatory language of the clan.

Irish Constitutional Nationalism at Westminster is a contradiction in terms. Even before Partition and Independence, when it was 80 strong and held the balance of power, it failed to achieve its very moderate object of making Ireland a Home Rule participant in the Empire. Since Partition it has been nothing but the flimsiest of fig-leaves helping to disguise the systematically undemocratic nature of Northern Ireland government.
At home in the Six Counties it is neither one thing nor the other—neither British nor Irish in any effective way. It was founded 46 years ago. During 28 of these years a Republican War was fought, and it routinely condemned the acts of war along the way, repeating that there was another way and that it stood for that other way—to do what?—to make United Irelanders of the Protestants, and to do it by peaceful persuasion.

The current SDLP leader, Colm Eastwood, urged the Unionists to attend an all-Ireland forum to discuss the problem that Brexit poses for Ireland. He reassured them that "those attending will not be sprayed with holy water at the door". This demonstrates that the fixed idea of Ulster Unionists as mere religious bigots, asserted 46 years ago, remains in place.
Everything that the SDLP hoped for in 1970, in the way of shaking Ulster Unionism out of its bigotry by breaking up its political structures and breaking the very tenuous connection of the UUP with the Tories, was achieved, but Unionism still stood its ground. And, all the SDLP can do is echo itself from 1970—giving Newton Emerson the opportunity to say something sensible:


"The implication is that unionist objections to all-Ireland co-operation are of a piece with deranged religious bigotry. Lest anyone accuse this in turn of being a gratuitous sectarian insult, the SDLP carefully directed its statement at "political unionism". This is a phrase used to separate unionist people from their politics, so it is of a piece with the dismissal of unionism as a false consciousness" (Irish Times, 20.10.16).



CONTENTS
Constitutional Nationalism!. Editorial
2017: Another Safe Budget. John Martin
Trump v Clinton. Editorial
Readers' Letters: Who broke the Syria ceasefire?. David Morrison
John Gillespie. Obituary
Shorts from the Long Fellow (The Irish Times; Budget 2017; Budget 2012; Project Eagle; Theresa May; Brexit; Ireland and Brexit
How America Made Europe! Jack Lane
Appeal on the release of a State Paper case—Round 5. Jack Lane
Centenary Commemorations, Casement and Gavin Friday. Tim O’Sullivan
Hubert Butler: The DVD. Julianne Herlihy
The 1921 Cork Docks Strike And The Irish Times—And A Book Cover Explained. Manus O'Riordan
The Origins of the Long War in Historical Context. Dave Alvey
Foster's 'Uncertain Future'. Jack Lane.
Biteback: Kilmichael And Eunan O'Halpin. Niall Meehan
Southern Protestants and the State. Niall Meehan 19
Does It Stack Up? Michael Stack (Auditors and Accountants, Part 3)
Roger Casement Remembered At Pentonville. Donal Kennedy
EASTER, 1916. Erskine Childers
A Thinking Democracy. Seán Ó Riain